Ingredient

Why Natural Flavor is Bad for You

Flagged

A 'natural flavor' is a complex blend of substances extracted from natural sources, such as fruits, vegetables, spices, or meat, through processes like distillation or fermentation. These extracts are then concentrated to deliver a specific taste or aroma, but are not intended to provide nutritional value.

Why it’s in your food

The manufacturer’s reason.

Manufacturers use natural flavors to enhance, restore, or add a specific flavor profile to a food product consistently. They help create a desired taste experience without adding other ingredients that might alter texture or color.

Community scan data

How it shows up in the wild.

Found in 21 productswe’ve analyzed.

0

Rated Clean

18

Caution

3

Flagged

Where to find it

Products containing Natural Flavor.

18 products in our database.

KIND LLC

KIND Bars

Flagged

Too many industrial ingredients for Nonna!

SNACK BAR13/18 clean · Apr 15, 2026

Nugget Market

CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH ON WHEAT

Flagged

Too many industrial additives and mystery flavors!

OTHER33/42 clean · Mar 23, 2026

ANDRE-BOUDIN BAKERY

Mystery Cracker

Flagged

Enriched flour and many industrial additives.

CRACKER17/28 clean · Apr 15, 2026

SEMIFREDDI'S

SEMIFREDDI'S

Flagged

Enriched flour and artificial flavors are not traditional.

BREAD10/14 clean · 4w ago

PEPPERIDGE FARM, INC.

Milk Chocolate Cookies

Flagged

Enriched flour and hydrogenated oils spoil these cookies.

COOKIES13/23 clean · Apr 15, 2026

Unknown

Cocktail Sauce

Flagged

Mystery 'Natural Flavors' in this sauce!

CONDIMENT23/26 clean · Mar 16, 2026

TRADER JOE'S

Trader Joe's Cookies

Flagged

Too many strange, processed ingredients!

COOKIES15/26 clean · 1w ago

GERBER PRODUCTS CO.

Gerber Whole Grain Cereal

Flagged

Enriched flour and artificial vitamins are not traditional.

CEREAL7/22 clean · Apr 20, 2026

SNACKS GENERATION LLC

Nutrail Sweet & Crunchy Granola

Flagged

A crunchy mix of seeds and nuts, Nonna approved!

CEREAL10/15 clean · Apr 17, 2026

TRADER JOE'S

Vanilla Ice Cream Chocolate Wafer Cookies

Flagged

Enriched flour and carrageenan make this dessert suspect.

FROZEN27/40 clean · 1w ago

Trader Joe's

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Flagged

Too many industrial ingredients for cookies

COOKIES11/16 clean · 1w ago

NESTLÉ USA, INC.

Nesquik

Approved

Classic ingredients for a simple chocolate drink.

OTHER5/7 clean · Apr 20, 2026

TRADER JOE'S

Moca Cookies

Flagged

Too many industrial ingredients for Nonna's approval

COOKIES12/17 clean · 1w ago

GENERAL MILLS SALES, INC.

Fruit Snacks

Flagged

Corn Syrup and Modified Corn Starch are not traditional.

SNACK BAR8/13 clean · Apr 20, 2026

Gerber Products Co.

Gerber Biscuits

Flagged

Too many industrial ingredients for Nonna's kitchen!

BABY FOOD9/19 clean · Mar 17, 2026

PEPPERIDGE FARM, INC.

Pepperidge Farm Milk Chocolate Cookies

Flagged

Too many industrial ingredients, Nonna would disapprove!

COOKIES14/24 clean · Apr 15, 2026

THE QUAKER OATS COMPANY

Granola

Flagged

Too many processed ingredients for Nonna!

SNACK BAR12/21 clean · Apr 20, 2026

Mondelez Global LLC

Sour Patch Kids

Flagged

Artificial colors and flavors, corn syrup!

CANDY4/13 clean · Apr 20, 2026

FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

What does 'natural' mean in natural flavor?▾
In the context of 'natural flavor,' 'natural' means the flavor compounds are derived from natural sources, like plants or animals. However, the extraction and processing can be quite industrial, involving chemicals and high temperatures to isolate and concentrate the desired aromatic components.
How is a natural flavor made?▾
Creating a natural flavor involves scientists identifying aromatic compounds in natural ingredients. They then use various methods, such as solvent extraction, distillation, or fermentation, to isolate and combine these compounds to create a specific flavor profile that is stable and consistent for food products.
Why is 'natural flavor' considered a 'red' ingredient by Ask Nonna?▾
While originating from natural sources, 'natural flavor' often represents a highly processed and industrially created ingredient. Nonna wouldn't recognize the complex laboratory-based extraction and blending processes used to create these concentrated flavor compounds, making it far removed from a traditional home kitchen.

Check your own pantry.

Get notified when the iPhone app launches.